Skip to content

Home
Shop
Get Started
Our Story

Instagram

Home
Shop
Get Started
Our Story

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: ALL THE TREASURES

Filter:

Availability

0 selected

Availability

In stock (211 products)
Out of stock (4 products)

Price

The highest price is $55.95

$

From

$

To

Category

0 selected

Category

Animal Figures (5 products)
Arts & Crafts (46 products)
Bath Book Toys (2 products)
Bookmarks (1 product)
Coloring Books & Pads (17 products)
Commemorative Coins (3 products)
Decorative Stickers (23 products)
Educational Toys (16 products)
Games (6 products)
Hair Pins, Claws & Clips (1 product)
Jewelry (22 products)
Keychains (5 products)
Lip & Cheek Stains (2 products)
Lip Balms (8 products)
Note Cards (2 products)
Notepads (1 product)
Paper & Magnetic Dolls (1 product)
Pens (2 products)
Picture Frames (1 product)
Play Dough & Putty (18 products)
Pretend Professions & Role Playing (11 products)
Print Books (5 products)
Puzzles (6 products)
Sticky Notes (2 products)
Storage & Organization (3 products)
Stuffed Animals (14 products)
Toy Cars (1 product)

Sort by:

215 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

215 products

Availability

In stock (211 products)
Out of stock (4 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $55.95

$

From

$

To

Clear

Category

Animal Figures (5 products)
Arts & Crafts (46 products)
Bath Book Toys (2 products)
Bookmarks (1 products)
Coloring Books & Pads (17 products)
Commemorative Coins (3 products)
Decorative Stickers (23 products)
Educational Toys (16 products)
Games (6 products)
Hair Pins, Claws & Clips (1 products)
Jewelry (22 products)
Keychains (5 products)
Lip & Cheek Stains (2 products)
Lip Balms (8 products)
Note Cards (2 products)
Notepads (1 products)
Paper & Magnetic Dolls (1 products)
Pens (2 products)
Picture Frames (1 products)
Play Dough & Putty (18 products)
Pretend Professions & Role Playing (11 products)
Print Books (5 products)
Puzzles (6 products)
Sticky Notes (2 products)
Storage & Organization (3 products)
Stuffed Animals (14 products)
Toy Cars (1 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

215 products

3D Printed Dragon- 5” Turqoise

3D Printed Dragon- 5” Turqoise

Regular price $10.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.50 USD
3D Printed Dragon- 5” Gray Blue

3D Printed Dragon- 5” Gray Blue

Regular price $10.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.50 USD
You Are My Sunshine Coin

You Are My Sunshine Coin

Regular price $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.99 USD
Reward Tokens - The MEGA Set (42 pieces)

Reward Tokens - The MEGA Set (42 pieces)

Regular price $55.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $55.95 USD
Girls Day With Mom Token Set - 10 pieces

Girls Day With Mom Token Set - 10 pieces

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Elementary Reward Token Variety Set - 10 pieces + 1 Treasure Box Token Freebie

Elementary Reward Token Variety Set - 10 pieces + 1 Treasure Box Token Freebie

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Mini 3D Printed Dragon – Lavender with 💕s

Mini 3D Printed Dragon – Lavender with 💕s

Regular price $9.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.50 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bear

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bear

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Piggy

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Piggy

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Reward Tickets - Bows and Stripes

"I did it!" Reward Tickets - Bows and Stripes

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
The Ticket Bank - Blue

The Ticket Bank - Blue

Regular price $24.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.95 USD
The Ticket Bank - Clear

The Ticket Bank - Clear

Regular price $24.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.95 USD
The Ticket Bank - Pink

The Ticket Bank - Pink

Regular price $24.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.95 USD
3D GELLIES

3D GELLIES

Regular price $13.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.00 USD
GEO STICKS VIBRANT TEMPERA PAINT STICKS - NEON

GEO STICKS VIBRANT TEMPERA PAINT STICKS - NEON

Regular price $10.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.00 USD
Twice as Nice 2 Color Click Pen

Twice as Nice 2 Color Click Pen

Regular price $4.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.00 USD
Morse Code Necklace - Gold - BFF

Morse Code Necklace - Gold - BFF

Regular price $13.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.00 USD
Hoops with Drop - Flower - FLOWER

Hoops with Drop - Flower - FLOWER

Regular price $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 USD
Around the World Mini Coloring Roll

Around the World Mini Coloring Roll

Regular price $6.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.99 USD
Geometric Animals Mini Memory Match Game

Geometric Animals Mini Memory Match Game

Regular price $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.99 USD
House of Novelties Checkers

House of Novelties Checkers

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Liberty Artemis Shaped Bookmark

Liberty Artemis Shaped Bookmark

Regular price $7.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $7.99 USD
Penguin Stack-up Wooden Balancing Game

Penguin Stack-up Wooden Balancing Game

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Little Letters of Love

Little Letters of Love

Regular price $9.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.95 USD
Coloring Book With Stickers: Wild World

Coloring Book With Stickers: Wild World

Regular price $6.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
Ocean Coloring Book + Stickers

Ocean Coloring Book + Stickers

Regular price $6.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
Rainbow Animals Mini Coloring Roll

Rainbow Animals Mini Coloring Roll

Regular price $7.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $7.99 USD
Little Letters of Thanks

Little Letters of Thanks

Regular price $9.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.95 USD
Coloring Book With Stickers: Dinosaurs

Coloring Book With Stickers: Dinosaurs

Regular price $6.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
Mocha Moments, Picking Pad, Fidget Toy

Sold out

Mocha Moments, Picking Pad, Fidget Toy

Regular price $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 USD

Sold out
Candy World - Picking Pad, Fidget Toy

Sold out

Candy World - Picking Pad, Fidget Toy

Regular price $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 USD

Sold out
Kids Lunch Love Notes

Kids Lunch Love Notes

Regular price $9.95 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.95 USD
Unicorn KidDough Play Kit

Unicorn KidDough Play Kit

Regular price $24.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
Ice Cream KidDough Play Kit

Ice Cream KidDough Play Kit

Regular price $24.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
Ocean Explorer KidDough Play Kit

Ocean Explorer KidDough Play Kit

Regular price $24.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
Valentines "I Dig You" Construction KidDough Play Kit

Valentines "I Dig You" Construction KidDough Play Kit

Regular price $22.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $22.99 USD

1
2
3
…
6

ALL THE TREASURES

ARTS & CRAFTS

ACCESSORIES

THE KINDNESS COLLECTION

TREASURES UNDER $10

PUZZLES & GAMES

STICKERS

Subscribe to our emails

Email

Instagram

Payment methods

© 2026, Collecting Joy Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Refund policy
Shipping policy
Contact information
Terms of service

Privacy Policy
|
Return Policy
|
Terms of Service
|
Shipping Policy

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.