Skip to content

Home
Get Started
Build Your Reward System
Treasure Box Finds
- Shop by
  
  New Arrivals
  All the Treasures
  $10 or Less
  Age: Tweens
- Things to Do
  
  Coloring & Crafts
  Dough
  Pretend Play Pads
  Games & Puzzles
  Stickers
- Things to Love
  
  Kid-Friendly Beauty
  Jewelry
  Key Chains
  Kindness Collection
- Just for Fun
  
  Fidgets & Squishies
  Stationary
  Bookmarks
Our Story

Instagram

Home
Get Started
Build Your Reward System

Shop Full Reward SystemEverything you need to start rewarding great behavior.

Reward BanksYour reward system deserves a chic and cozy home and this is it.

Reward TicketsThe in-the-moment incentive that makes good behavior click.

Reward TokensOur #1 bestseller and once you see them in action, you'll understand why.

Get OrganizedThe tools that keep your reward system running smoothly.
Treasure Box Finds
Shop by
New Arrivals
All the Treasures
$10 or Less
Age: Tweens

Things to Do
Coloring & Crafts
Dough
Pretend Play Pads
Games & Puzzles
Stickers

Things to Love
Kid-Friendly Beauty
Jewelry
Key Chains
Kindness Collection

Just for Fun
Fidgets & Squishies
Stationary
Bookmarks
Our Story

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: Products

Filter:

Availability

0 selected

Availability

In stock (352 products)
Out of stock (12 products)

Price

The highest price is $39.95

$

From

$

To

Category

0 selected

Category

Animal Figures (1 product)
Arts & Crafts (59 products)
Bookmarks (1 product)
Coloring Books & Pads (16 products)
Commemorative Coins (5 products)
Decorative Stickers (35 products)
Educational Toys (23 products)
Erasers (3 products)
Games (4 products)
Hair Pins, Claws & Clips (1 product)
Highlighters (1 product)
Jewelry (23 products)
Jewelry Boxes (1 product)
Keychains (9 products)
Lip & Cheek Stains (2 products)
Lip Balms (8 products)
Markers (1 product)
Note Cards (3 products)
Notepads (4 products)
Pens (2 products)
Picture Frames (1 product)
Play Dough & Putty (19 products)
Play Dough Sets (1 product)
Post Cards (1 product)
Potty Training Kits (1 product)
Pretend Professions & Role Playing (14 products)
Print Books (5 products)
Puzzles (9 products)
Sensory Toys (11 products)
Standard Erasers (1 product)
Standard Sharpeners (1 product)
Sticky Notes (2 products)
Storage & Organization (3 products)
Stuffed Animals (12 products)
Tote Bags (1 product)
Toy Cars (1 product)
Toys (99 products)
Wooden Pencils (1 product)

Sort by:

363 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

363 products

Availability

In stock (352 products)
Out of stock (12 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $39.95

$

From

$

To

Clear

Category

Animal Figures (1 products)
Arts & Crafts (59 products)
Bookmarks (1 products)
Coloring Books & Pads (16 products)
Commemorative Coins (5 products)
Decorative Stickers (35 products)
Educational Toys (23 products)
Erasers (3 products)
Games (4 products)
Hair Pins, Claws & Clips (1 products)
Highlighters (1 products)
Jewelry (23 products)
Jewelry Boxes (1 products)
Keychains (9 products)
Lip & Cheek Stains (2 products)
Lip Balms (8 products)
Markers (1 products)
Note Cards (3 products)
Notepads (4 products)
Pens (2 products)
Picture Frames (1 products)
Play Dough & Putty (19 products)
Play Dough Sets (1 products)
Post Cards (1 products)
Potty Training Kits (1 products)
Pretend Professions & Role Playing (14 products)
Print Books (5 products)
Puzzles (9 products)
Sensory Toys (11 products)
Standard Erasers (1 products)
Standard Sharpeners (1 products)
Sticky Notes (2 products)
Storage & Organization (3 products)
Stuffed Animals (12 products)
Tote Bags (1 products)
Toy Cars (1 products)
Toys (99 products)
Wooden Pencils (1 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

363 products

"Hooray - I Read Today!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Pink

"Hooray - I Read Today!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Pink

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I Am Amazing" Behavior Reward Tickets - Daisies

"I Am Amazing" Behavior Reward Tickets - Daisies

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bear

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bear

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bunnies

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Bunnies

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Cat

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Cat

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dinosaur

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dinosaur

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dog

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dog

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dogs

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Dogs

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Pandas

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Pandas

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Piggy

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Piggy

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Soccer

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Soccer

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Unicorn

"I did it!" Behavior Reward Tickets - Unicorn

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Reward Tickets - Bows and Stripes

"I did it!" Reward Tickets - Bows and Stripes

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"I did it!" Rewards Tickets - Baseball Drip

"I did it!" Rewards Tickets - Baseball Drip

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"Love You To Pieces..." - Red w/ Red + Pink Confetti

Sale

"Love You To Pieces..." - Red w/ Red + Pink Confetti

Regular price $5.50 USD

Regular price ~~$8.00 USD~~ Sale price $5.50 USD

Sale
"Read A Book" Behavior Reward Tickets

"Read A Book" Behavior Reward Tickets

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
"Roll With It" Retro Skate Sticker

"Roll With It" Retro Skate Sticker

Regular price $3.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.00 USD
"This Girl is on Fire" Pen -Pink w/Pink Confetti

Sale

"This Girl is on Fire" Pen -Pink w/Pink Confetti

Regular price $5.50 USD

Regular price ~~$8.00 USD~~ Sale price $5.50 USD

Sale
"Today Is A Great Day To Be Proud Of Yourself" Sticker

"Today Is A Great Day To Be Proud Of Yourself" Sticker

Regular price $3.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.50 USD
"Treat Yourself Like Someone You Love" Inspirational Sticker

"Treat Yourself Like Someone You Love" Inspirational Sticker

Regular price $4.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.00 USD
"Use the Potty" Behavior Reward Tickets

"Use the Potty" Behavior Reward Tickets

Regular price $10.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.99 USD
24 Crayon Rocks with Muslin Bag

Sale

24 Crayon Rocks with Muslin Bag

Regular price $7.00 USD

Regular price ~~$10.00 USD~~ Sale price $7.00 USD

Sale
3D GELLIES

3D GELLIES

Regular price $13.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.00 USD
3D Printed Crystal Dragon - 5” Gold

3D Printed Crystal Dragon - 5” Gold

Regular price $11.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $11.00 USD
3D Printed Dragon- 5” Gray Blue

3D Printed Dragon- 5” Gray Blue

Regular price $10.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.50 USD
3D Printed Dragon- 5” Turqoise

3D Printed Dragon- 5” Turqoise

Regular price $10.50 USD

Regular price Sale price $10.50 USD
5" Plush Bamboo Panda Palm Pal

5" Plush Bamboo Panda Palm Pal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Hedgie Hedgehog Palm Pals

5" Plush Hedgie Hedgehog Palm Pals

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Meow Kitty Palm Pal

5" Plush Meow Kitty Palm Pal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Airy Avocado Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

5" Plush Pal Airy Avocado Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Ashley Iced Coffee Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

5" Plush Pal Ashley Iced Coffee Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Barnie Owl Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Sale

5" Plush Pal Barnie Owl Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $8.40 USD

Regular price ~~$12.00 USD~~ Sale price $8.40 USD

Sale
5" Plush Pal Beau French Bulldog Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

5" Plush Pal Beau French Bulldog Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Bunny Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

5" Plush Pal Bunny Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Deon Daisy Flower Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

5" Plush Pal Deon Daisy Flower Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.00 USD
5" Plush Pal Flo Watering Can Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Sale

5" Plush Pal Flo Watering Can Palm Pals Stuffed Animal

Regular price $8.40 USD

Regular price ~~$12.00 USD~~ Sale price $8.40 USD

Sale

1
2
3
…
11

ALL THE TREASURES

ARTS & CRAFTS

ACCESSORIES

THE KINDNESS COLLECTION

TREASURES UNDER $10

PUZZLES & GAMES

STICKERS

We’re a family-owned business helping kids feel proud of their progress, and making it easier for parents to celebrate and motivate them along the way.

Quick Links

Home
Get Started
Our Story
Shop Full Reward System
Fill Your Treasure Box

Get in Touch

hello@collectingjoy.co

Follow us on Instagram →

Join the Joy

Get updates, exclusive offers and new product drops.

Email

Payment methods

© 2026, Collecting Joy Powered by Shopify

Privacy policy
Refund policy
Shipping policy
Contact information
Terms of service

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.